DoorDash vs. Instacart: which is better for drivers?
One has you grabbing bags off a counter. The other has you pushing a cart. Here's how they compare.
DoorDash is faster-paced restaurant delivery that peaks at lunch and dinner. Instacart has you shop grocery orders yourself, so each order takes longer and is bigger. Neither is better for everyone, and many drivers run both: DoorDash at mealtimes and Instacart in between.
DoorDash and Instacart are both delivery apps, but the work feels very different. This comparison sticks to how the jobs differ. Pay varies too much by area, hours and order to rank fairly.
DoorDash vs. Instacart at a glance
| DoorDash | Instacart | |
|---|---|---|
| The work | Pick up a prepared order and deliver it | Shop the order in the store, then deliver it |
| Time per order | Short | Longer, because you shop first |
| Order size | A bag or two | Anything from a few items to a full cart |
| Busiest times | Lunch and dinner | Spread through the day, strong on weekends |
| Minimum age | 18 | 18 |
| Car needs | Almost any car | Cargo room helps a lot |
| Physical demands | Light | Walking the store and lifting heavy orders |
What Dashing is like
You accept an order, drive to the restaurant, grab it and drop it off. Orders are quick, so you do a lot of them, and your day is shaped by the lunch and dinner rushes. Most of your time is driving and waiting at restaurants. Requirements are loose: see DoorDash car requirements in Arizona.
What Instacart shopping is like
You accept a batch, shop it yourself, check out and deliver. You spend more time in the store than on the road, and customers may message you about replacements. Orders can be heavy, with cases of water and bulk items, so it's more physical. See Instacart car rental in Phoenix for the shopper requirements.
Which car works for both?
DoorDash rewards gas mileage because you're driving constantly. Instacart rewards cargo space because orders are big. A hybrid hatchback covers both, which is why so many delivery drivers end up in a Prius. See the best car for delivery driving.
Insurance differences
DoorDash maintains third-party liability coverage that applies during active deliveries. Instacart expects shoppers to rely on their own auto insurance. In both cases your own policy needs to cover delivery driving, and neither app will fix your car. The details are in delivery insurance in Arizona.
Which should you choose?
- Choose DoorDash if you want quick orders, less lifting, and you're free at lunch and dinner.
- Choose Instacart if you don't mind shopping, want fewer miles per hour worked, and have room for big orders.
- Choose both if you want to stay busy all day. Dash the meal rushes and shop in the afternoon lull.
For timing, see the best time to DoorDash in Phoenix. For the other apps, see the best delivery apps to drive for in Phoenix.
One rental for both apps
Valley Gig Rentals rents Toyota Prius hatchbacks by the week to delivery drivers in the Phoenix area, and you can use the same car on DoorDash, Instacart and other delivery apps. It's $250 a week with your own delivery-approved insurance or $350 a week with coverage arranged through us, with routine maintenance included.
Frequently asked questions
Is DoorDash or Instacart better for drivers?
It depends on the work you prefer. DoorDash is quick restaurant delivery that peaks at mealtimes. Instacart has you shop grocery orders, so each one takes longer and is more physical. Many drivers run both.
Can you do DoorDash and Instacart at the same time?
Yes. You're an independent contractor on both, so you can be signed up for both and switch between them. Take one order at a time so neither delivery runs late.
Do you need a bigger car for Instacart than DoorDash?
It helps. Instacart orders can fill a cart, so cargo space matters. A hatchback with fold-down seats handles most orders.
Which is easier to start, DoorDash or Instacart?
Both have a minimum age of 18 and a background check. DoorDash has slightly looser requirements and no shopping to learn, so most people find it quicker to start.
Can I use one rental car for DoorDash and Instacart?
Yes. A rental from Valley Gig Rentals is for delivery work in general, so the same Prius can be used on DoorDash, Instacart and other delivery apps.